Compare federal job offers
Put two offers side by side: pay, take-home, step increases, promotions, bonuses, loan help and leave. Then see what you can still negotiate before you say yes.
Offer B is worth about $88,385 more over five years, and $27,408 more in year one. Offer A reaches GS-12 step 4 ($98,459) by year 5. Offer B reaches GS-12 step 5 by year 5 on step increases alone.
| Item | Offer A | Offer B | B minus A |
|---|---|---|---|
| Yearly payBasic pay plus locality | $74,678 | $102,415 | +$27,737 |
| Take-home per paycheckAfter taxes, retirement and 5% to the TSP | $2,115.34 | $2,591.82 | +$476.48 |
| Agency TSP money1% automatic plus 4% match, if you put in 5% | $3,721 | $5,103 | +$1,382 |
| Hiring bonus, per yearSpread over the service agreement | $0 | $0 | — |
| Student loan repaymentPer year, up to $10,000 | $0 | $0 | — |
| Annual leaveHours a year | 104 hrs | 104 hrs | — |
| Commute costPer year | $0 | $3,000 | +$3,000 |
| First-year valuePay, agency TSP, bonus, loan help and leave, minus commute | $81,865 | $109,272 | +$27,408 |
| Five-year valueWith step increases and ladder promotions at today's pay tables | $490,128 | $578,513 | +$88,385 |
With 0 years of creditable service you'd earn 4 hours per pay period. Ask for non-federal experience to count before you accept: it can move you to 6 or 8 hours.
Estimate at 2026 pay tables. Take-home assumes no health plan and 5% to the traditional TSP; the agency adds 5%. Promotions are assumed once a year up to the promotion potential. Taxes are withheld from hiring bonuses and loan repayments, and both require a service agreement.
What you can and can't negotiate
The grade. It comes from the job announcement and your qualifications. The locality pay for the duty station is set by law.
A higher starting step, credit toward your annual leave rate, a recruitment bonus, student loan repayment, paid moving costs, your start date and telework, all in writing.
Your private-sector salary or a competing offer. Since 2024, agencies setting GS pay may not consider non-federal salary history, including the salary in another job offer, and shouldn't ask for it. Earlier federal pay is different; see "highest previous rate" below.
Starting above step 1
- New to federal service: "superior qualifications." If you're getting your first federal civilian job (or coming back after a break of at least 90 days), the agency can start you at any step up to 10. You need qualifications well above the minimum, or skills the agency especially needs.
- Make the case with facts the agency has to weigh: the steps given to similar new hires, how far above the minimum your skills are, what the private sector pays for them, how hard the job has been to fill, turnover, and what a delay would cost the agency.
- Who approves: someone at least one level above the hiring supervisor, in writing, before you start.
- Current or former feds: "highest previous rate." If you've held a federal job, the agency can set your step to match the highest rate you earned before (based on the GS base rate, not locality). It's at the agency's discretion and follows its written policy, so ask before the personnel action is processed.
Leave credit for your experience
New feds earn 4 hours of annual leave per pay period (13 days a year), 6 hours after 3 years of service (20 days) and 8 hours after 15 years (26 days). The agency can count your non-federal work, or military service if you're a military retiree, toward those years if the experience is directly related to the job.
- Example: 5 years of related private-sector work credited on day one puts you at 6 hours per pay period instead of 4: 56 more hours of vacation a year.
- Ask before you start. It can't be added later. You'll need proof of the prior work.
- Stay a year. The credit becomes permanent after one full year with the agency. Leave earlier, and it's removed (the leave you already earned is kept).
Hiring bonuses, moving costs and loan repayment
| Item | How much | The catch |
|---|---|---|
| Recruitment incentiveNew hires | Normally up to 25% of yearly basic pay for each year you agree to stay, up to 4 years. Since Feb. 13, 2026, agencies can approve up to 50% a year on their own for critical needs. Never more than 100% of a year's pay in total. | You sign a service agreement of up to 4 years. If you leave early you may owe some of it back; read the agreement before you sign. |
| Relocation incentiveCurrent feds who move | Same limits, for a hard-to-fill job in a different area | Service agreement of up to 4 years at the new location |
| Student loan repayment | Up to $10,000 a year, $60,000 total, paid to your loan holder | At least a 3-year service agreement. It's taxable. Agencies can't use it to recruit someone already working for another agency. |
| Moving costs | Travel and shipping your household goods to your first duty station | Optional for the agency. You agree to stay 12 months. See moving for the job. |
Incentives are paid through payroll with taxes withheld; federal withholding on extra payments like these is usually a flat 22%. They don't count as basic pay for retirement.
Other things that differ between offers
- Locality and special rates: a GS-12 step 1 job pays about $22,000 more in San Francisco than in the Rest of U.S. in 2026, and some jobs have special rates higher than locality pay. See locality vs cost of living.
- Promotion potential: a GS-9 job with potential to GS-12 can out-earn a GS-11 job with no ladder within a few years. The calculator above shows this.
- Retirement contributions: most new hires pay 4.4% of pay toward FERS. If you had 5 or more years of federal civilian service by the end of 2013, you may pay 0.8% instead.
- Probation: 1 year in the competitive service, and 2 years for most excepted-service jobs (1 for veterans' preference eligibles). VA doctors and nurses serve 2 years. Since 2025, your agency must certify in writing that keeping you is in the public interest before probation ends. See workplace rules.
- Schedule: check whether the job is in the competitive service, excepted service or the new Schedule Policy/Career, which has no adverse-action appeal rights. See your rights at work.
- Telework and remote work: since the January 2025 return-to-office memo, this varies by agency and job. Get it in writing. See schedules and telework.
- Health insurance into retirement: you need to be on a federal health plan for the 5 years right before you retire to keep it. Worth knowing if you're starting late in your career.
When to negotiate
- Tentative offer. This is when to ask. Reply in writing with what you'd like: step, leave credit, bonus, loan repayment, moving costs, telework and start date, with a short case for each.
- Background checks. Fingerprints and forms like the SF-85 or SF-86 start once you accept the tentative offer. See security clearances.
- Final offer. It sets your start date, usually the beginning of a pay period. Make sure every approval and service agreement is signed before then.
- First week. Check your first SF-50 for your step and your leave category. Fix mistakes right away.
Leaving the military? See how a GS offer compares with your military take-home in military pay vs. a GS offer.
VA clinicians: your pay is set differently, mostly through market pay. See pay systems beyond the GS and student loans for the Education Debt Reduction Program.
Next steps:New to federal hiring? Start hereSecurity clearances
Sources: 5 CFR 531.212 and 531.221 (pay setting), 630.205 (leave credit), part 575 (incentives, including the Feb. 2026 waiver rule), part 537 (student loans), 5 U.S.C. 5723 (moving costs) and Executive Order 14284 (probation), checked Nov 1, 2026. Your HR office has the final word.
Last reviewed Nov 16, 2026 against the official sources below. How we keep FedStub accurate