FedStub
Open Season is openNov 9 – Dec 14· Compare 2027 health plans →Find my best planMy plan
← All calculatorsCalculator

Roth or traditional TSP?

Both grow the same way. The difference is when you pay the tax: now (Roth) or when you take the money out (traditional).

Traditional, after tax$26,703$6,000 pre-tax, taxed at 18% later
Roth, tax-free$24,749$4,560 after paying 24% now
Difference$1,954in favor of traditional

Traditional comes out ahead because you expect a lower tax rate in retirement. One contribution, grown for 25 years.

The one-line rule

If you expect a higher tax rate in retirement than now, Roth wins. Lower, traditional wins. Same rate, it's a tie.

Early career? Lean Roth.

Your pay, and likely your tax rate, will rise. Paying tax now at a lower rate usually comes out ahead.

The match is always traditional

Agency money goes in pre-tax no matter what you choose, so you already own some of each.

Can't decide? Split it.

Many people put half in each. It hedges against future tax changes.

Converting money you already have

Since Jan. 28, 2026, you can move traditional (pre-tax) Thrift Savings Plan (TSP) money into Roth inside the TSP. This is called an in-plan Roth conversion. Current and former employees can do it, and so can surviving spouses with a TSP beneficiary account. Non-spouse beneficiaries and alternate payees (people paid from your account under a court order) can't.

  • Size and number: each conversion must be at least $500, your vested balance must be at least $500, and you can make up to 26 conversions a calendar year.
  • No withholding: the pre-tax amount you convert is taxable income for that year, and the TSP can't withhold any tax from it, even if you ask. Plan to pay the tax from other money, such as savings.
  • Mutual Fund Window money has to be moved back into the core TSP funds before it can be converted.
  • Required minimum distributions: in a year you owe one, it has to be paid in full before a conversion is processed.

The one-line rule above applies here too: converting pays off if your tax rate in retirement will be higher than the rate you pay on the conversion now.

Estimates use 2026 IRS, OPM, SSA and state tax rules. How we calculate and our sources → · Who decides each line →

More on the TSP:TSP fundsPaycheck plannerTSP loansWithdrawals in retirement

Last reviewed Nov 3, 2026 against the official sources below. How we keep FedStub accurate

Illustration only. Compares the same take-home cost: a traditional contribution versus the smaller Roth contribution that costs you the same today. Ignores state-specific rules and required minimum distributions.