FedStub
Open Season is openNov 9 – Dec 14· Compare 2027 health plans →Find my best planMy plan
← VAVA · Compare

Compare a VA physician offer with another offer

Salaries alone don't tell you which offer pays more. A VA offer has market pay, performance pay, possible incentives and loan repayment, a TSP match, a pension and malpractice protection; a hospital or group offer may have bonuses, a retirement match and malpractice premiums or tail coverage you pay for. Enter both offers to see them side by side, per year and per hour.

Two offers

The VA offer

Base pay at step 1: $124,308. Base plus market pay: $274,308.

The other offer

Estimate

Difference in yearly value

The other offer is $11,977 more

VA: $288,023 a year, about $138 an hour. Other offer: $300,000 a year, about $115 an hour.

A year, before taxesVAOther
Salary (VA: base plus market pay)$274,308$300,000
Performance pay or bonus$0$0
Incentive or signing bonus, per year$0$0
Loan repayment$0$0
CME$0$0
Retirement contribution (VA: TSP)$13,715$0
Malpractice or tail you pay$0$0
Total$288,023$300,000
Per hour$138$115

Not added above: each year at VA also earns a FERS pension of 1% of your high-3 pay, about $2,743 a year in retirement at this pay, for life.

An estimate for one year before taxes, not a promise of pay. VA base pay: VA's 2026 schedule; limits from 38 U.S.C. 7431; TSP: 1% automatic plus up to 4% matching when you put in 5%; pension: 1% of high-3 pay per year of service under 5 U.S.C. 8415. Health insurance, leave and taxes differ by offer and aren't added; EDRP is tax-free, most other pay isn't.

What's counted, and what isn't

  • Counted for VA: base plus market pay, the performance pay you expect (within VA's limits), an incentive spread over its service agreement, EDRP or SLRP for the year, CME up to $1,000, and VA's TSP contributions.
  • Counted for the other offer: salary, bonus, a signing bonus spread over the years you commit to, the employer's retirement contribution, loan repayment and CME, minus malpractice or tail coverage you'd pay yourself.
  • Shown but not added: the FERS pension each VA year earns, because its value depends on how long you stay.
  • Not counted: health insurance, disability and life insurance, leave and holidays, and taxes. Compare those separately; VA's health plan share and leave are in the offer calculator.

Questions that change the answer

  • Is the other bonus guaranteed? Productivity bonuses tied to RVUs or collections can vary a lot from year to year.
  • Who pays for malpractice and tail? At VA, claims about your VA care go against the United States. Elsewhere, ask whether the policy is claims-made or occurrence and who pays the tail when you leave.
  • How much call, and is it paid? VA physicians don't get extra pay for call. Hours a week, call included, is the fairest way to compare.
  • What happens if you leave early? Both a VA incentive and a signing bonus may have to be paid back in part.
  • How does PSLF fit? VA counts as a qualifying employer; many nonprofit hospitals do too, while for-profit groups don't.

Why compare per hour?

An offer that pays more but asks for 60 hours a week can pay less per hour than one with a 40-hour week. The table shows each offer's yearly value divided by 52 weeks of the hours you enter. It ignores leave, so treat it as a rough guide.

FedStub is independent. It isn't affiliated with or endorsed by the Department of Veterans Affairs.

Last reviewed Nov 16, 2026 against the official sources below. How we keep FedStub accurate